moonbattery.gif


« God Save the Queen | Main | The Limits of Multiculturalism »

February 05, 2006

Safe Self-Harm

Clean needles for junkies, Medicaid-reimbursed Viagra for sex offenders, and now this:

Patients who want to harm themselves could be given clean blades and advice on where to cut, under plans drawn up by nurses' leaders. ... Senior nurses working with mental health patients have drawn up the proposals for "safe self-harm" to be debated in April by the Royal College of Nursing. ... If the nurses' proposals are adopted, patients could be taken to a safe place where they would be watched and given advice while they cut themselves.

The RCN's mental health adviser Ian Hulatt observes,

There is a clear comparison with giving clean needles to reduce HIV.

Yes, as V the K pointed out, both are excellent examples of loopy liberal policies enabling destructive behavior.

But Jeremy Bore, vice-chairman of the RCN's prison forum, thinks it's a great idea:

My instinct is that it is better to sit with the patient and talk to them while they are self-harming. We should definitely give advice on safer parts of the body to cut.
It could get to the state where we could have a discussion with the patient about how deep the cuts were going to be, and how many.

It looks like the spirit of egalitarianism that underlies Britain's socialized medicine has led to the lunatics running the asylums.

self-mutilation.jpg
Don't worry: the nurse made sure everything was sterilized.

Posted by Van Helsing at February 5, 2006 04:28 PM

Comments

Nihilism gone wrong? Sheesh. I think someone did not just lose their moral compass but had gotten one in a box of Cracker-Jacks and tossed it away as a crummy prize.

Posted by: Anna at February 5, 2006 09:24 PM

Just when you think youve heard of everything along comes yet more left wing nut insanity.

Whats next nurses monitoring people huffing spray paint or gasoline?


Posted by: General Jack D. Ripper at February 5, 2006 09:42 PM

Whatever happened to the oath? "Do no harm . . ."

Or have they decided that "mental trauma" from not being able to indulge in a self-destructive habit outweighs the physical damage these people would inflict on themselves?

Posted by: Hal at February 5, 2006 10:52 PM

Try browsing through online journals written by young (18-24yo) women and finding more than a handful who aren't self-described "cutters".

It always struck me as a particularly sick bid-for-attention behavior in these cases, particularly loathsome for the matter-of-fact nature with which they discuss it...as though it were simply another anxiety-management tool, like counting ten or breathing exercises. Oh, but don't dare suggest that their self-admitted (if not self-promoted) cutting behavior is somehow an aberration for which they ought to seek help, lest you suffer the Wrath of the Insufficiently Worshipped Victim, in the form of a shrill journal entry bemoaning your lack of sensitivity to all the big and small traumas of their dysfunctional childhood (itemized in great detail, with adramatis personae, year-by-year timeline, index and concordance).

Which is not to say that some rare individuals aren't afflicted with a true pathology causing such behavior. There just seems to be an air of victim-cult trendiness to the first-person accounts I have come across.

Posted by: prince of leaves at February 5, 2006 10:59 PM

Prince, you might be right in some respects re the "cultishness" of self-mutilation. Though it is true (more often than you might think) that self-destructive behavior such as self-cutting is a very real psychopathology. I know people with tendancies toward this and it is but one of several ways one can harm onesself -- overeating is another, even more common mode, leading to disasterous health problems, not least of which is type II diabetes. Alcoholism is another.

That said: this "let's help them cut" bidness? There is no excuse for this loony crap coming out of the "sensitive" medical community. Such patients should be put on watch, given extra coping sessions with their therapists, or forced to take their meds.

Putting it on the same par with handing out clean needles to prevent HIV only underscores the psychopathology of these "health professionals" (if you dare use the term).

Posted by: The MaryHunter at February 6, 2006 06:35 AM

OK, I confess - I misunderstood this one at first. I thought the comment "show them where to cut" meant they would be showing the most EFFECTIVE route to suicide, so the patients wouldn't have to suffer. Instead, I see these barkers are trying to keep the patients safe. "better to sit with the patient and talk to them while they are self-harming" - What possible words of wisdom do you have to offer? "Yes, that's a nice cut, there. That one's bleeding much better than the last try."

Bark! Bark! Bark! Flap! Flap! Flap!

Every time I think it's gotten as bizarre as it can get, they surprise me again. Stake these dudes, Van Helsing, before they rise again.

Posted by: The Random Yak at February 6, 2006 12:09 PM

VH, over at my place, DL has explored this safe self-harm phenom a bit more and came up with a rather impressive list of other ways that the loony libs can (and in some cases do) enable this madness. He'd actually locked and loaded this post sometime yesterday I think, I'd been unable to post until now.

Posted by: The MaryHunter at February 6, 2006 03:26 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)